In this project, I set out to learn what kind of images comprise the representation ofthe !Kung San in etnographic works and film. I discuss hunter-gatherer ethnographic works, comparing the images found in past works to present ethnography. I also make an anthropological and philosophical inquiry about the subject of truth and relativity in representation, and discuss the massive debate over objectivity and subjectivity in ethnography. In conducting the analysis of the film, The Gods Must Be Crazy, I discovered that the movie perpetuates images ofthe !Kung San as a "pristine" and "isolated" society. The stereotype of the "primitive Other" parallels images found in early ethnographic observations of the San. I suggest that cultural representations, such as ethnographies, are partially subjective in nature. For the future of hunter-gatherer studies, I propose that we take into consideration a revisionist approach: the !Kung San are not an "isolated" society, contrary to what early depictions imply; nor is there culture destroyed. Different cultures have various belief systems, and in order to decipher these we must engage in intense research, and minimize our ethnocentric ideas by adopting a cultural relativistic perspective. In addition, when perceiving cultural representations, we should consider the following: an element of reflexivity in the representation as well as our own reflectivity, the ethnographic present of the work we are observing, and the methods used by the researcher to collect the cultural information. Perhaps with these considerations, we can get past the partial subjectivity of ethnography, and the problem of truth and relativity, and really get to the "heart" of the culture. The presence of cultural diversity in our surroundings can provide a beautiful theater for our performance as one human race, only enabled by mutual understanding.
Kardulias, P. Nicholas
Sociology and Anthropology
Kasmai, Nikoo R., "Cultural Representation of the !Kung San in Film and Ethnography: Implications of Our Perceptions About the Cultural "Other"" (1998). Senior Independent Study Theses. Paper 6349.
Bachelor of Arts
Senior Independent Study Thesis
Available for download on Thursday, January 01, 2150
© Copyright 1998 Nikoo R. Kasmai